Talkie.ai vs Pretty Good AI Comparison: Which Should Your Practice Choose?

Talkie.ai and Pretty Good AI both use AI agents to support your front desk across calls, texts and online channels, and write the results into your EHR. Talkie has been building voice AI since 2018 and runs one AI front desk agent across calls, texts, webchat and forms on five EHRs. Pretty Good AI, founded in 2025, builds only for athenaOne and also sells modules for referrals, prior authorization and billing. Here is how the two compare, using public sources only.

Last reviewed October 14, 2026 · 8 min read

Which one fits your practice?

Pretty Good AI works only with athenaOne and sells back-office modules alongside its voice and text agents.

Talkie is a great fit when the AI front desk is the priority. It runs on five EHRs including athenaOne, so you keep the same AI front desk if you add a practice or switch systems, and it answers in 50+ languages. Of the practices that pilot Talkie, 9 in 10 stay on as long-term partners.

How Talkie.ai and Pretty Good AI compare

How do Talkie and Pretty Good AI compare on athenaOne?

Pretty Good AI builds for athenaOne and nothing else, and argues that single-EHR depth is what sets it apart.

Talkie goes deep on athenaOne too. It’s been an athenahealth Marketplace partner since 2024, a listing that meant passing athenahealth’s own evaluation and testing, and an approved vendor for Privia Health, whose practices run on athenaOne. On athenaOne, Talkie’s agent:

• Schedules, reschedules and cancels against providers’ live availability, in the right appointment type and department, so nobody has to fix bookings later.
• Creates a new patient chart and books the first visit on the same call, so new patients don’t drift elsewhere while waiting for a callback.
• Captures refill requests in athenaOne and lets the patient know when the refill is ready, so routine refill calls stop tying up your lines.
• Files patient cases from messages and voicemails, including priority cases when a patient needs a fast callback, so urgent requests reach the right person instead of sitting in voicemail.
• Verifies patients, routes calls and runs outreach: waitlist offers, confirmations, reminders and recall of overdue patients.

Can you see each integration working before you choose?

Talkie publishes recorded demos of its athenaOne workflows, from scheduling and refills to patient cases, new patient intake and confirmations, in a YouTube playlist.

A full integration webinar shows the agent booking appointments and creating new patient charts in athenaOne, followed by audience Q&A.

Pretty Good AI’s site doesn’t link to recorded demos of its athenaOne workflows. It offers live demos on a strategy call instead.

Recordings let you see exactly what each workflow writes into athenaOne before you talk to anyone, so a demo call can go straight to how Talkie would fit your schedule.

What if you’re not on athenaOne, or might not stay on it?

Beyond athenaOne, the gap between the two gets even wider. Pretty Good AI states that it doesn’t connect to any other EHR. Talkie builds native EHR integrations for four more systems: ModMed EMA, Elation Health, AdvancedMD and eMedicalPractice.

EHR breadth matters most in three situations:

• You’re not on athenaOne. If your practice runs ModMed, Elation, AdvancedMD or eMedicalPractice, Pretty Good AI can’t serve you today.
• You run several separate practices on different EHRs. An MSO or a growing organization can put one AI front desk across all of them instead of one vendor per system.
• You might change EHRs. A front desk agent that already works on your next system is one less thing to replace.

What getting started and support look like with each vendor

Pretty Good AI charges no setup fee and makes the first 30 days live free.

Talkie provides a dedicated implementation team that works with you to configure the agent to your workflows and connects your EHR and phone system. Every partnership starts with a paid 90-day pilot on your real calls. Because the pilot is paid, it’s a real commitment on both sides: Talkie’s team tunes the agent to your practice and reviews calls regularly, so issues get caught and fixed early. Ninety days is long enough to see real results on your own call volume before you decide, and 9 in 10 practices that pilot Talkie stay on as long-term partners. To help patients get comfortable with the AI agent, Talkie also published a patient adoption checklist.

What to ask both vendors: of the practices that started a pilot or a free month, how many are still live a year later, and why did the others leave?

How much do Talkie and Pretty Good AI cost?

Both vendors build a final quote around your size, call volume and workflows. They differ in what they show you before the first call.

Pretty Good AI doesn’t publish rates; it prices per location, per provider and per call, with the first 30 days live free.

Talkie publishes where its pricing starts:

• Plans start at $1,000/month. That covers about 5,000 minutes of AI work, or roughly 2,500 patient calls.
• Busy months cost 20¢ per extra minute, so a seasonal spike doesn’t force a plan change.
• Every partnership starts with a paid 90-day pilot. After it, stay month-to-month or sign for 12 months at 20% off.
• Separate practices can save by signing together. When three or more distinct practices sign up together, implementation is free for all of them.

When Talkie is the right fit for your practice

Talkie is built to be the AI front desk for independent practices and groups, on the EHR you already use. It’s likely the right pick if:

• You run athenaOne, ModMed EMA, Elation Health, AdvancedMD or eMedicalPractice, or manage separate practices on different EHRs, so one AI front desk can serve all of them.
• You want a vendor whose core product is the AI front desk, with one agent across calls, texts, webchat and forms, so patients never have to repeat themselves.
• Your patients speak English, Spanish, Korean or one of 50+ other languages, and should get help in their own language at any hour.
• You’re on athenaOne or in the Privia network, and want a partner both athenahealth and Privia have vetted, with recorded demos of each workflow.
• You want to know where pricing starts before the demo, then prove the results in a 90-day pilot on your own calls.

If you spot something out of date, write to contact@talkie.ai and we will fix it.

Frequently asked questions